After my little scare in the snow and continuing dissatisfaction with my backpack carrier, we
decided it was time to investigate and invest in some winter gear. I thought that this would be an easy education followed by a routine trip to buy shoes. Boy, was I in for it.
I'll start with shoes because they are actually the simplest thing we went shopping for. You see, winter hiking shoes (snow boots) are everywhere. You can buy them at Target. In fact, I did buy a pair at Target when we lived in Michigan. The best thing I can say about that pair of shoes is that they were warm. All other aspects of comfort were lost if I wore them longer than the time it took to brush the snow off of my car. The ready availability of winter boots is probably the biggest stumbling block when you're looking for good ones.
I was able to narrow the field a bit because I have a specific purpose in mind:
dayhiking. I need boots that are (1) waterproof, (2) warm and (3) comfortable for long walks. For me,
comfort is connected with fit, ergonomics and flexibility. I have pretty easy feet to fit (no extra width or height to my arches or anything else unusual) so I thought that comfort would be the simplest part of the equation. Wrong again.
I spent some time online reading shoe ratings. This is often helpful, especially when the person rating the product leaves a good narrative. My wife was able to select a pair of boots based on the recurring complaint that the specific boots were "too flexible" and lacked any ankle support. This was exactly what she was looking for (even for hiking). Her ankles are amazingly rigid and the only injury she's ever had to them was from falling off a pair of platform sandals about 8 years ago. Interestingly, fewer men post reviews to the shoes they buy. So I could see early on that I was on my own.
We went to 2 national retail sporting goods stores on Saturday. Never mind which ones because I don't really have anything nice to say about them. The first had a VERY limited selection of snow boots (fewer than 3 styles and only one brand) and the second offered very little technical expertise on the products that they did have. Della found the boots that she liked (and ended up buying) but no one was there to give any helpful advise. Overall, the day shopping left us both discouraged about the random nature of the buying decision.
We went back to the
Internet on Saturday night and looked for reviews of the specific brands and styles that we had tried on. Della was pretty sure of what she wanted, but we wanted to check out one more store. I asked her if she'd be
embarrassed if I just wrapped plastic shopping bags around my feet.
We went to
REI on Sunday. We went straight to shoes without browsing because it was the weekend before Christmas and the crowds were outrageous. They keep the bulk of their shoes stocked in the back room, so there were 3 sales associates on the floor helping customers. In spite of being busy, all of them were taking the time to assist customers in their selections. Consultative sales is a challenge, my wife and I have both done it, but these guys made it look like fun. They seemed genuinely interested in helping us make a good decision and offering the advice of people who don't just know their products, but use them as well. They have a little hill to climb in the store and hiking socks to try shoes on with. I have never shopped for shoes like that. They had the boots that Della wanted and I found a pair that are perfect.
Since that worked out so well, we went in search of some new thermals for Della. The associate in that department was also
knowledgeable about the products (though less inclined to make a recommendation). We also bought socks, which would also have been overwhelming had we not already done some online investigating...Who knew there were SO many options? In the end, all three of us got new
SmartWool socks. One lady that reviewed the
SmartWool on the
REI website says that if they get wet, you can wring them out and put them back on.
The shopping was also aided by the presence of a kid-sized table and chairs in the shoe department with crayons and paper. Elle was also excited to climb up and down the shoe test-structure and as long as one of us was with her, the sales associates were
ok with that too.
REI also has a great loyalty program which we also purchased. Benefits of the program include no-questions-asked returns, access to special sales events and quarterly rebate cash. It is a lifetime membership with a one-time fee of $15.
REI has consumer reviewed products for sale at
www.rei.com and closeouts at
www.reioutlet.com. Both sites also have detailed product descriptions and photos.
This weekend, we purchased:
Scrambler winter boots by Salomon(r) for Tim ($110)
...waterproof, antimicrobial and rated to -25 degrees F
...true fit and very comfortable, top offers support without impeding mobility
Nuptse Fur winter boots by The North Face(
tm) for Della ($99)
...waterproof, antimicrobial and rated to -40 degrees F
...hiking tread but Della says it's "like wearing socks"
...very stylish look
SmartWool(r) socks for Tim (med cushion...$14), Della (women's med cushion...$15) and
Eliana (2 pairs Baby
Woolly...$18)
REI women's thermal underwear bottom for Della ($30)
...Della has a mild sensitivity to wool, so silk is a 2
nd best natural fiber option
...She likes the fit a lot...haven't had a chance to try out the warmth
NOTE: This is not a commercial site in the truest
sense and (except for products at Amazon.com) I receive no compensation for products that I recommend. This is a review based upon my personal experience with the stores, websites or brands listed. While we try to comparison shop and make purchases based upon reasonable criteria, we are a family and as such unable to field test multiple products. Recommendations are NOT paid endorsements.